Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case
First reported by Litnews ·
The price of standard computer memory could be impacted by the outcome of this ongoing antitrust lawsuit against major DRAM manufacturers.
A federal judge in California has refused to dismiss a proposed class-action lawsuit accusing Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron of conspiring to limit the supply of conventional DRAM chips. U.S. District Judge Noël Wise determined that the plaintiffs plausibly alleged an agreement to cut conventional DRAM production and shift capacity to High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) for AI accelerators. The court distinguished this case from a prior dismissal of a similar suit, citing specific factors such as long-term HBM contracts, refusals of conventional DRAM contracts, a brand closure, fab delays, and the companies' history of price fixing. While some arguments were deemed insufficient, the judge found that the combination of alleged actions, particularly the pivot to HBM and reduced conventional DRAM output despite record prices, suggested a conspiracy rather than independent market behavior. The defendants must now respond to the allegations by December 7, 2026, with a case management conference scheduled for January 12, 2027.
The court's refusal to dismiss the DRAM price-fixing case signals a potential shift in how antitrust allegations are viewed in the semiconductor industry, particularly when combined with strategic pivots to high-demand products like HBM. Judge Wise's emphasis on "plus factors" beyond mere parallel conduct suggests that companies will need to be exceedingly careful to document independent decision-making when shifting production and capacity, especially given the market's concentrated nature and past cartel activity.
This ruling directly affects consumers and businesses relying on conventional DRAM for their computing needs, as it allows a claim that manufacturers colluded to artificially inflate prices. The progression of this case could lead to significant damages if the conspiracy is proven, potentially influencing future pricing strategies and supply chain management within the memory chip market and setting a precedent for similar future litigation.
AI-written summary. May contain errors.