Static

DNS resolvers are the wrong place to fight piracy

First reported by Techstackups ·

The signal ●○○○ Compiled by AI from Techstackups and Hacker News
Why you might care

You must change your DNS resolver if you rely on Quad9 for security filtering and live in France.

What happened

Quad9, a non-profit DNS resolver known for blocking malware and phishing domains, has announced it will cease serving French users on November 24, 2026. This decision follows a Paris court order fining Quad9 for refusing to block specific sports-streaming piracy domains on behalf of beIN Sports. The court cited a French sports code article that allows rights holders to seek blocking orders against "any person able to help stop the infringement," which Quad9 argues unfairly targets DNS resolvers. With approximately 20 similar cases pending in France, Quad9 states that the cumulative penalties would be financially unsustainable for the organization. Cloudflare, another major DNS provider, characterized Quad9's departure as an early warning sign for the internet infrastructure sector. Quad9 was founded in 2017 by the Global Cyber Alliance, IBM, and Packet Clearing House, and its privacy promises are backed by Swiss law.

What it means

France's legal approach, targeting DNS resolvers for copyright infringement, is creating an unsustainable operating environment for non-profit internet infrastructure providers. By obligating services like Quad9 to block specific domains, or face accumulating daily fines, the country forces a choice between global blocking (impacting non-French users) or non-compliance, as precise geo-blocking is technically challenging and legally contested. This places an immense financial and operational burden on entities that, unlike large corporations, lack extensive legal and technical resources to fight such cases, potentially leading to their withdrawal from the market and reduced service availability for their users.

The situation signals a broader tension between national regulatory efforts to combat online piracy and the decentralized, global nature of internet services. As more countries consider similar legislation, the precedent set in France could lead to a fragmented internet where users in different regions experience varying levels of access based on their location and their chosen DNS provider's willingness or ability to comply with local laws. This could force users to choose between privacy-focused, security-oriented resolvers and those that prioritize compliance, potentially impacting cybersecurity efforts and user privacy globally.

AI-written summary. May contain errors.

Tech