Meta discussed attacking Jonathan Haidt — now even his haters are annoyed
First reported by The Verge ·
Academic critiques of social media's impact on teens will face greater scrutiny for potential corporate influence.
Meta Platforms reportedly considered a "Whisper strategy" in 2023 to undermine academic support for researcher Jonathan Haidt, whose forthcoming book, "The Anxious Generation," argues that social media harms children's mental health. Court filings revealed Meta employees discussed plans to "turn academics against Haidt," potentially by enlisting critics like Andrew Gelman to publish negative pieces. Despite Meta's alleged strategy, the revelation has provoked backlash from both Haidt and many of his academic critics. Several prominent academics, including Candice Odgers and danah boyd, have publicly stated that their critiques of Haidt's work are independent and not influenced by Meta. Andrew Gelman and Chris Ferguson, who have previously critiqued Haidt, have also denounced Meta's alleged tactics and affirmed their independence from the company, with Gelman clarifying past research funding from Meta was unrelated. The court filings are part of ongoing lawsuits against Meta regarding the safety of its platforms for teenagers.
The alleged Meta strategy, aimed at manipulating academic discourse, reveals a disturbing escalation in corporate efforts to control public narratives surrounding technology's societal impact. By targeting researchers like Haidt, Meta apparently sought to preemptively discredit criticism before it gained widespread traction, mirroring tactics historically used by industries to suppress unfavorable science. This "Big Tobacco playbook" approach not only threatens the integrity of scientific debate but also highlights the vulnerability of academic research to undue corporate influence.
The incident underscores a growing tension between independent academic inquiry and the powerful interests of tech giants. While researchers like Haidt and his critics maintain their autonomy, the mere suggestion of Meta's interference erodes public trust in scholarly findings. Future research on social media's effects may need to proactively address and document potential conflicts of interest to assure the scientific community and the public of their objectivity.
AI-written summary. May contain errors.