Static

Quad9 Is Leaving France: Why DNS Resolvers Are the Wrong Place to Fight Piracy

First reported by Techstackups ·

The signal ●○○○ Compiled by AI from Techstackups and Hacker News
Why you might care

If you use Quad9's 9.9.9.9 DNS service in France, your internet access will stop working on November 24, 2026, unless you switch to a different resolver.

What happened

Quad9, a non-profit DNS resolver known for blocking malware and phishing domains, has announced it will cease operations in France on November 24, 2026. This decision follows a Paris court ruling that fined Quad9 €1,000 per day for refusing to block a list of pirate sports-streaming domains on behalf of beIN Sports. The court cited Quad9's own malware-blocking capabilities as evidence that it could implement the requested blocks. Quad9 argues that it cannot comply with such orders because it does not geolocate users and blocking for all users globally would infringe on international users' access. The ruling stems from a French law allowing rights holders to seek blocking orders against entities that can help stop infringements, which has expanded to include DNS resolvers. With approximately 20 similar cases pending in France, Quad9 states that the cumulative penalties would be an existential threat to the organization. Cloudflare, another major DNS resolver, characterized Quad9's departure as a warning sign for the industry.

What it means

France's legal strategy to combat online piracy by targeting DNS resolvers is creating a challenging environment for organizations that prioritize user privacy and lack the resources of larger tech companies. The court's reasoning, that Quad9's ability to block malware globally implies it can block infringing content for specific regions, sets a precedent that could compel similar actions against other privacy-focused services. This approach may inadvertently push users towards less secure or less privacy-respecting alternatives, or force even non-profit resolvers into adopting methods that compromise their core principles to remain operational.

The departure of Quad9 from France and Cloudflare's warning signal a potential shift in how online content regulation is enforced. It highlights the difficulty for non-profit or privacy-centric entities to navigate complex legal landscapes designed for commercial entities with extensive legal and technical teams. The industry should anticipate increased scrutiny on DNS providers, potentially leading to a bifurcation where some resolvers comply with broad blocking orders, while others withdraw from jurisdictions with such strict enforcement, impacting user choice and the availability of privacy-preserving services.

AI-written summary. May contain errors.

Quad