Sources: the UK's proposed under-16 social media ban is expanding to target recommender systems and user content, including YouTube Kids, Lego Play, and Spotify
First reported by The Guardian ·
Services with recommender systems or user-generated content now risk being unavailable to under-16s in the UK.
The UK government is significantly expanding its proposed ban on social media for under-16s, potentially including platforms like YouTube Kids, Lego Play, and Spotify. Initial plans focused on traditional social media but have broadened to encompass recommender systems and user-generated content. Sources indicate up to 150 platforms could be affected. The regulations, set for cabinet approval this week and parliamentary tabling in December, aim for a comprehensive approach to prevent children's exposure to online harms. Companies are reportedly concerned that disabling recommender systems would render their services non-functional. The ban is intended to be integrated into the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act, with a second phase of regulations targeting e-commerce platforms like Vinted and eBay planned for spring. Platforms can be removed from the banned list by demonstrating compliance with the regulations and eliminating harmful functions.
This expansion signals a government push toward regulating the core mechanics of online content delivery, not just explicit social networking features. By targeting recommender systems, the UK government is directly confronting the addictive or harmful algorithmic curation that underpins many digital platforms. This broader scope could force a fundamental re-evaluation of how online services operate and engage young users, potentially leading to a bifurcated internet experience for those under and over 16.
The inclusion of platforms like Spotify and Lego Play suggests regulators are moving beyond a narrow definition of 'social media' and are instead focusing on the potential for any online service to facilitate harmful interactions or algorithmic influence. The ambiguity and broadness of the proposed regulations are causing significant concern among tech companies, who argue that essential functions like content recommendation are integral to their service's viability and cannot be easily disabled without rendering them unusable.
AI-written summary. May contain errors.